Back Shelf Beauties
by Willie Waffle

Lions For Lambs 

Tom Cruise stars as Senator Jasper Irving – an up-and-coming star in the Republican Party who has been selected to present a new military strategy in Afghanistan to reporter Janine Roth (Meryl Streep).  Meanwhile, Arian Finch (Derek Luke) and Ernest Rodriguez (Michael Pena) are two soldiers in Afghanistan who are on the first mission of this new strategy.  Also, at the same time, professor Stephen Malley (Robert Redford) is trying to inspire a talented young student, Todd Hayes (Andrew Garfield), who has become disinterested in class.

Will anyone listen? 

Lions for Lambs plays like a college theater project earnestly attempting to argue everything about the war against terror from the public’s reaction to the press coverage to the military strategies and the politics around it, but seems to be preaching to the choir who watch the same debates on CNN and Fox News each day. It doesn’t make it more compelling or interesting just because Tom Cruise is prettier than Bill O’Reilly.   

Writer Matthew Michael Carnahan and director Redford don’t present anything new or daring unless you have been out of touch with daily news events, but maybe that is the point.  Maybe Carnahan and Redford want to stir up debate among people who aren’t paying attention, but Lions for Lambs isn’t stimulating enough to do so, and is reaching out to an audience trying to avoid those news programs and discussions when they go to the movies.  With average material, Lions for Lambs guarantees the target audience will head off to Saw IV or Bee Movie.  The cast is the only drawing power here.   

Cruise is good, avoiding playing the senator as some sort of caricature, giving him some soul and a belief in what he is presenting.  Streep is perfect as the reporter trying to dig through the spin and figure out if this new tact will work, while also trying to maintain some respect for the figure before her (and, like a good reporter, challenging while also making sure the subject doesn’t get so angry as to cut off the interview).  Meanwhile, Redford is perfectly natural and captivating as he lectures in a loving way.    

Lions for Lambs might want to light a fire under people and get them to be more active in today’s debate, but you can’t light a fire without a spark, and this movie doesn’t have enough heat to provide that spark.

1 ½ Waffles (Out of 4)

Lions for Lambs is rated R for some war violence and language

Copyright 2007 - WaffleMovies.com

You can support this site by shopping at AllPosters.com Click here to buy posters!