Back Shelf Beauties
by Willie Waffle

Gone Baby Gone 

Don’t feel you need to be Gone Baby Gone from the theater just because Ben Affleck wrote and directed the movie (yes, THAT Ben Affleck, but don’t start screaming in dread or letting visions of Gigli dance in your head).  He’s pretty good at doing both, so stick around for a movie you want to see. 

Casey Affleck stars as Patrick - a small time private investigator in Boston who specializes in finding troubled people (like junkies) who have gone missing.  It’s not a glamorous business, but it has given him a certain reputation within the community.

Patrick, like everyone else in town, has become fascinated with the sad case of a small little girl who seems to have been kidnapped from her bedroom when her mother, Helene (Amy Ryan), dashed across the street for a moment.  The family has asked Patrick and his partner/girlfriend, Angie (Michele Monaghan), to get involved in the investigation – equally working with the police and digging around where the police cannot go.

Will Patrick and Angie be able to find the little girl before it is too late?  Is there more to the story than we realize?

OF COURSE THERE IS SOMETHING MORE TO THE STORY THAN WE REALIZE!  We wouldn’t have a movie if there wasn’t more to the story than we realize.  I just wish director Ben Affleck would play up that mystery a little bit better.  Also co-written by Affleck and Aaron Stockard (based on the book by Dennis Lehane), Gone Baby Gone feels too much like three distinct parts of a movie that have some trouble going together.  Affleck needs to provide a better flow for the movie, so the audience’s energy and curiosity is always being fed, instead of giving us three breaks or breathers.  At one point, I felt like Gone Baby Gone was over, only to realize we had another act to go.  It results in a clumsy connection between all three acts instead of one complete mystery and story. 

Also, Affleck has a tendency to overdirect Gone Baby Gone.  He beats us over the head with images of the “real” Boston or the underbelly of Boston as we are inundated with a series of images like the beat up buildings, the people who are missing teeth and the bars where nobody wants to know your name, and you don’t want to know theirs.  Yes, we need to realize this is a strange subculture of a modern metropolitan American city, but it gets a bit too cartoonish at times.    

However, I would be happy and excited to see another Ben Affleck directed movie.  He does a fantastic job getting the best possible acting performances from every person in the cast, and he makes the audience aware of the competition between Patrick and the Boston police, which adds the needed tension to get the audience involved.  Plus, Affleck’s strongest contribution to the screenplay and movie is making the audience aware that Gone Baby Gone is more than a kidnapping mystery.  It’s also a messy morality tale forcing the audience to consider the gray areas between what is right and wrong.               

Gone Baby Gone also features some fantastic acting from big names you know and a small name you better get to know.  Casey Affleck, who put in an amazing (possibly Oscar worthy) performance in The Assassination of Jesse James By The Coward Robert Ford, scores again as the street tough kid with a sharp mind and something to prove.  More than anything, Affleck helps us understand the morality play portion of the movie when Gone Baby Gone evolves from being a crime drama into a movie about making a very crucial, difficult decision.  We see the pain on his face as Affleck shows us the conflict going on in Patrick, and how he wants to do the right thing even in the face of many people telling him he is wrong. 

While Morgan Freeman and Ed Harris put in very good performances in roles you might not be accustomed to seeing them in, it is Amy Ryan who steals the movie from all of the big names.  As the trashy mother with questionable parenting skills and something more to hide, Ryan is the embodiment of this underworld Ben Affleck wants to bring to the fore.  She puts in a realistic and show stopping performance that would have become overly bombastic and scenery chewing if it wasn’t for her ability to know when to go for it, and when to dial it down enough to make Helene a human being instead of a cliché or stereotype.       

Gone Baby Gone is a strong directorial debut by a guy who could use a break, and proves he has what it takes to be involved in making movies for a long time.  The next Clint Eastwood?  Maybe it’s too early to tell, but not out of the question.

3 Waffles (Out of 4)

Gone Baby Gone is rated R for violence, drug content and pervasive language

Copyright 2007 - WaffleMovies.com

You can support this site by shopping at AllPosters.com Click here to buy posters!